Hair Tie Types Compared: Elastics, Spiral Ties, Scrunchies, Claw Clips and Buckles

Short answer: most hair damage from a hair tie happens on the way out, when the tie gets dragged down the length of your hair. Every hair tie type below handles that moment differently. A buckle hair tie is the only type that opens instead of sliding off, so nothing gets pulled through your hair at all.

Hair tie types at a glance

Basic elastic

Comes out: rolled or dragged down the ponytail
Sports hold: strong
Best for: cheap backups
Trade off: snags and pulls on removal, stretches out, snaps

Seamless elastic

Comes out: rolled or dragged down the ponytail
Sports hold: strong
Best for: everyday ponytails
Trade off: no metal join to catch, but removal still drags hair

Spiral or coil hair tie

Comes out: twisted and pulled off
Sports hold: medium
Best for: fewer ponytail dents, loose styles
Trade off: can tangle into curly or thick hair, stretches over time

Silk or satin scrunchie

Comes out: slid down the ponytail
Sports hold: light to medium
Best for: sleep, fragile hair, low friction
Trade off: bulky, often loosens during sprints and tumbling

Claw clip

Comes out: unclipped
Sports hold: weak for running and jumping
Best for: updos at a desk, quick twists
Trade off: hard to lie down or wear a helmet with, slips with movement

Buckle Hair Tie

Comes out: click the buckle open and it unwinds
Sports hold: strong
Best for: sports, thick or fine hair, men's buns
Trade off: costs more than a basic elastic, and the buckle goes on the outside loop

Buckle Scrunchie

Comes out: click the buckle open and it unwinds
Sports hold: medium to strong
Best for: everyday wear, curly and thick hair
Trade off: more visible than a slim elastic

Which hair tie type doesn't pull or snag?

Any tie you slide off has to travel down your hair, so friction and snagging happen no matter how smooth the material is. Silk and seamless ties reduce the friction. A buckle removes the slide entirely: press the buckle, it clicks open, and the tie unwraps out of your hair. Shop hair ties that don't pull or snag.

Best hair tie type for thick hair

Thick hair needs a tie with enough length to wrap without overstretching. The Buckle Hair Tie is an 8 inch, 3 mm extra stretchy elastic that goes around most thick ponytails in about 2 wraps, and two can be linked for extra thick or long hair. Scrunchies work well too if you want a softer hold. See hair ties for thick hair.

Best hair tie type for fine or thin hair

Fine hair needs more wraps, not a tighter elastic. Wrap a Buckle Hair Tie 4 or more times for a secure hold, then click it open at the end of the day. See hair ties for fine hair.

Best hair tie type for guys and men's buns

A slim black or brown elastic disappears into a man bun or short ponytail. The problem is taking it out, when short hair gets yanked. A buckle opens instead, so it comes out clean. See hair ties for guys.

Best hair tie type for running, volleyball, cheer and gymnastics

Sports need a tie that stays put through impact and sweat. Elastics hold best, scrunchies and claw clips tend to slip. The Buckle Hair Tie gives elastic level hold with a release that doesn't drag sweaty hair. See hair ties for running and gifts for female athletes.

Hair tie or scrunchie for breakage?

A fabric scrunchie spreads tension over more surface, so it's gentler on fragile hair while it's in. A thin elastic holds tighter with less bulk. Either way, the biggest breakage moment is removal, which is why both the Buckle Hair Tie and the Buckle Scrunchie use the same buckle.

Prices

Buckle Hair Tie: $4.99 for one, $12 for a 5 pack, $21 for a 10 pack, $40 for a 20 pack, and a 100 pack for teams at $100. Buckle Scrunchies from $8.40. Every buckle has a 100 year warranty. More answers in the FAQ.